Proxy Season Close
This proxy season Friends Fiduciary has continued to engage corporations to improve impacts on people and the planet. While uncertainty remains around how far the SEC will push back on shareholder rights, Friends Fiduciary and fellow faith-based and values-aligned investors have continued to bring companies to the table and continued to see successes.
This proxy season we’ve engaged with over 45 companies on issues ranging from climate and sustainability to human rights and sound governance. We filed a total of 18 resolutions and were lead filer on 7 of those. With the bulk of the proxy cycle winding down in June, we can share some of the highlights from this season.
Strong Vote Results
There were several shareholder resolutions we filed that received strong investor support at corporate annual meetings, including two proposals requesting the separation of chair and CEO positions filed at State Street and Eli Lilly, receiving 23% and 33% support respectively. This governance structure has long been accepted as best practice, and has maintained significant support from investors at large, with ISS reporting that 81 percent of investors responding to its policy survey indicated a preference for an independent chair. These governance engagements also give us the opportunity to raise other issues with companies, especially where we suspect that concentrated governance could exacerbate other concerns.
We also co-filed a proposal this year at PepsiCo, asking the company to assess the effectiveness of upholding its human rights standards across its value chain. This stems out of increasing concerns around human rights risks in the company’s cane sugar supply chain, particularly in Latin America and in Southeast Asia, where reporting has shed light on poor worker treatment in India’s Maharashtra region. The proposal received over 16% investor support.
We were also the lead filer of a proposal at Kroger, the food retailer, asking the company to disclose how it will increase the pace of its GHG reduction efforts. As a food retailer, Kroger relies heavily on agricultural supply chains that are particularly susceptible to climate change disruptions, and yet Kroger lags peers on strategies and disclosures around how Kroger is mitigating these risks. The proposal received over 17% investor support.
While majority votes are uncommon, they are often not necessary to drive company progress. Given current headwinds facing shareholder rights and the significant pullback of large asset managers and proxy advisory firms on environmental and social risks, these votes, at this time, signify clear investor concern and send a message to companies that these are prominent risks that need to be addressed.
Successful Withdrawals
We also had a number of shareholder proposals where we were able to come to an agreement with companies and withdraw. This includes a proposal at Pfizer on the alignment of the company’s political contributions with its stated values and interests related to its vaccine business. A proposal at Chipotle also resulted in a withdrawal when the company agreed to update its language to reflect how the company ensures alignment of its lobbying activities with its stated values around paying a living wage. Another successful withdrawal at Tractor Supply confirmed the company’s commitment to continue sustainability reporting and continue to evaluate scaling up ongoing environmental initiatives, including energy efficiency and renewable energy opportunities.
Raising Concerns with Companies through Dialogue
In addition to these shareholder proposal results, we’ve also continued dozens of dialogues with the companies we hold, allowing us to bring Quaker values to corporate leadership. We’ve continued to speak to companies about sustainability concerns, including setting science-based targets and developing planning and strategies to decrease GHG emissions. We’ve also continued conversations focused on protecting human rights, including in our tech company engagements and engagements around living wage, workers’ rights, the human right to health, and the importance of diversity and inclusion at the workforce and board level. In these conversations we’re finding that, despite the changes at the SEC, most companies remain willing to meet with shareholders and hear our perspective on the critical concerns we have as long-term investors.
Our Values in Proxy Voting
At the end of every proxy season, we evaluate our proxy voting record. Friends Fiduciary has custom proxy voting guidelines that align with broadly held Quaker values. Voting our proxies provides us the opportunity to not only support shareholder proposals that seek better corporate policies and practices, but to also vote against management proposals to demonstrate dissatisfaction with corporate governance. This includes voting against CEO pay packages that reflect excessive executive compensation. This season we voted against 65% of proposed CEO pay packages. We also voted against directors for election at 66% of companies. We vote against directors for a number of reasons, whether it be the use of a dual class structure, lack of director independence, a lack of follow-through on sustainability commitments, or a lack of diversity on the board. Proxy voting remains another important tool to signal our concerns as long-term investors.
Continue the Work
We are living through an era of increased politicization around issues that present material, financial risk. But Quaker testimonies remain the guiding light in this work–values Friends have held for generations and will carry into the future. At Friends Fiduciary, we will continue to bring these values to corporations to push for an economy that works for all.
